Conservative management of closed extra-articular metacarpal hand fractures: A scoping review.
文献摘要
Background Metacarpal (MC) fractures account for up to 44% of hand injuries, primarily affecting working-age adults. Despite their prevalence and significant socioeconomic impact, conservative management approaches vary widely. The current key concepts, gaps, and nature of existing treatment evidence for MC fractures are not clearly defined. Purpose To identify and map the breadth of literature regarding the conservative management of extra-articular MC fractures and identify existing gaps in clinical evidence. Study design Scoping review METHODS: Following the Arksey and O'Malley framework and PRISMA-ScR guidelines, a systematic search of five databases (CINAHL, Cochrane, MEDLINE, EMBASE, and PubMed) was conducted through September 2025. Research questions focused on the nature of evidence, types of interventions, and differences in treatment based on fracture location. Results Thirty-four studies were included (n=2857 participants), comprising eleven RCTs, fourteen observational studies, and nine secondary/qualitative reports. Narrative synthesis revealed significant heterogeneity in orthotic design, immobilization duration, and clinical governance. A key evidence gap was identified in therapeutic management beyond the acute (0-6-week) healing phase. Outcome measures were inconsistent, complicating the comparison of functional recovery across protocols. Conclusions Conservative MC fracture management lacks standardization. Future research should prioritize methodologically robust trials using standardized core outcome sets, with a specific focus on the role of advanced practice hand therapy in late-stage functional rehabilitation.