知镜 Cognispect · 医学文献与研究工作台

Recovering from stigmatised loss following child removal into state care: a realist synthesis of institutional mechanisms shaping maternal health and inequality.

McGovern R, Smiles C, Grant C, Alderson H, De Backer K, Brennan-Tovey K, Powell C, Lhussier M.
Social science & medicine (1982) · 2026-10-27 · PMID 42950481

文献摘要

Background The removal of a child into state care is a profoundly traumatic event for mothers, with enduring consequences for mental health, wellbeing, and social marginalisation. Policy and intervention responses following child removal have largely prioritised the prevention of recurrent care proceedings or rapid repeat pregnancy, little is known about the mechanisms through which support may facilitate recovery, resist stigma, and shape longer-term trajectories. Methods We conducted a realist synthesis to examine how, for whom and under what circumstances interventions may work (or not) to support mothers following child removal. Drawing on academic literature, service evaluations, and stakeholder expertise, we developed and refined programme theories through iterative searching, contextualised data extraction, and theory testing, in line with RAMESES standards. Analysis integrated sociological and psychological theory, including stigma, narrative identity, and bereavement. Findings Child removal emerged as a form of stigmatised loss that disrupts maternal identity and constrains grief. Five interrelated mechanisms were identified through which interventions may support recovery: (1) compassionate responses at the point of removal enabling 'mothering from a distance'; (2) non-stigmatising relationships that reduce shame and isolation; (3) trusted support to make sense of care entry; (4) trauma-informed, post-removal engagement addressing unmet needs; and (5) future-oriented identity reconstruction beyond a spoiled maternal self. These mechanisms were highly contingent on relational quality, timing, and institutional context. Practices experienced as coercive, including mandated contraception, risked reinforcing stigma and undermining recovery. Conclusions By conceptualising child removal as a stigmatised loss and identifying the institutional mechanisms through which post-removal support shapes recovery, this study advances understanding of child removal as a health-shaping social process with implications for population health and health inequalities.

在知镜精读原文来源DOI 原文

知镜提供医学文献检索、阅读笔记、人体图谱、统计绘图与研究复现工具。