知镜 Cognispect · 医学文献与研究工作台

Improvement of Clinical Practice Guideline Appraisal by Human Experts and AI Agents by Using Structured Guidance: Systematic Review, Meta-Analysis, and Validation Study.

Mao X, Wang J, Wang Z, Zhang Y, Qiu S, Ye J, He S, Wang C, Xia Y, He C, Li K, Zhu S.
Journal of medical Internet research · 2026-08-26 · PMID 42647856

文献摘要

Background Rehabilitation clinical practice guidelines (CPGs) have increased rapidly, but inconsistent methodological quality limits their implementation. Although Appraisal of Guidelines for Research and Evaluation II (AGREE II) and Reporting Items for Practice Guidelines in Health Care (RIGHT) provide standardized appraisal frameworks, their application is time-consuming. Large language model (LLM)-based AI agents may offer a scalable alternative with uncertain reliability. Objective We evaluated rehabilitation CPGs' methodological and reporting quality and determined whether structured guidance improves human expert-AI agent agreement. Methods We systematically reviewed English- and Chinese-language rehabilitation CPGs from Embase, Scopus, PubMed, China National Knowledge Infrastructure, Wanfang Data, National Institute for Health and Care Excellence, Scottish Intercollegiate Guidelines Network, and Guidelines International Network up to June 2026. Methodological and reporting quality were assessed using AGREE II and the RIGHT checklist. Factors associated with guideline quality were examined using regression and subgroup analyses. Two AI agents were compared with human consensus with and without a structured guideline appraisal workbook, followed by external validation using 6 anterior cruciate ligament reconstruction CPGs. Results We included 227 CPGs (163 English-language, 64 Chinese-language). After introducing a structured guideline appraisal workbook, agreement among human experts improved markedly-mean intraclass correlation coefficients (ICCs) increased from -0.09 to 0.66 to 0.84-0.92 across AGREE II domains. Overall guideline quality remained low, with 35.9% (SD 18,8%) applicability and 52% (SD 17.2%) stakeholder involvement. English-language guidelines outperformed Chinese-language guidelines in scope and purpose (mean 74.64, SD 15.4 vs mean 68.88, SD 13.9; P=.004) and applicability (mean 39.14, SD 18.6 vs mean 27.54, SD 16.7; P Conclusions Rehabilitation CPGs, particularly Chinese-language CPGs, continue showing deficiencies in applicability and stakeholder involvement. LLM-based appraisal without structured guidance provides insufficient agreement. Structured guidance improved agent-human agreement, supporting AI-assisted guideline appraisal under human oversight. Although further validation across additional clinical specialties is needed, AI agents can serve as efficient assistants in guideline appraisal instead of replacing humans. Future synthesis requires human-AI integration guided by structured, expert-defined principles. Trial registration PROSPERO CRD420251270676; https://www.crd.york.ac.uk/PROSPERO/view/CRD420251270676.

在知镜精读原文来源DOI 原文

知镜提供医学文献检索、阅读笔记、人体图谱、统计绘图与研究复现工具。