Comparison of Compass and Humphrey Perimetry: Test-Retest Variability at Glaucomatous Scotoma Edges.
文献摘要
Prcis The Compass perimeter, despite its integrated eye-tracking, demonstrated similar variability at scotoma borders with 24-2 visual field testing in glaucoma patients compared with the conventional Humphrey Field Analyzer. Purpose Increased variability at the borders of glaucomatous scotomas, as measured with the Humphrey Field Analyzer (HFA), has been partly attributed to gaze instability. The Compass perimeter (CMP), which incorporates eye-tracking to compensate for gaze instability, may reduce variability along scotoma borders. This study determined the test-retest variability (TRV) at scotoma borders measured with the CMP and compared it with that of the HFA. Methods One eye of each glaucoma patient was tested with both the CMP (24-2 ZEST) and the HFA (24-2 SITA standard) during 3 visits (screening, baseline, and follow-up). Eyes were stratified by mean deviation (MD) into mild (MD>-6 dB), moderate (-12 dB ≤MD Results Twenty-nine eyes [31% women; median (IQR) age 64 (56-72 y)] were included. The mean (SD) time between baseline and follow-up was 6.4 (1.3) days. No statistically significant differences in SBP-TRV were found between CMP and HFA for all glaucoma stages combined (1.8 vs. 1.9 dB, P =0.42) or within individual stages. Conclusion CMP and HFA show comparable variability at scotoma borders with 24-2 VF testing, indicating no significant advantage of CMP eye tracking in reducing scotoma edge variability.